American Standard Cadet 3 Compact-Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet vs American Standard Cadet 3 FloWise Two-Piece Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet

Both Cadet 3 variants ($175-195) use the same Cadet 3 flush valve and EverClean glaze, identical 1.28 GPF rating, identical 1,000g MaP score. The difference is bowl shape and projection.

Bowl projection

The Cadet 3 Compact-Elongated has a 28.5-inch projection — a hybrid between round-front (28 inches) and full elongated (30-31 inches). It preserves most of the elongated interior comfort in a smaller footprint. The Cadet 3 FloWise has a full 30.5-inch elongated projection.

When bathroom space matters

For bathrooms under 51 inches of depth (50-inch is the typical small powder room), the Compact saves the 2 inches that prevent toilet bowl interference with vanity or wall. For larger bathrooms (master baths, full bathrooms), the FloWise full elongated is more comfortable.

Bowl interior

The Compact has a slightly smaller water surface area inside the bowl. Functionally similar but the larger elongated bowl on the FloWise creates marginally less splashing and feels more substantial.

Specs that match

Same comfort-height seat (16.5 inches), same 12" rough-in, same 1.28 GPF flush valve, same EverClean glaze, same 1,000g MaP, same trapway diameter, same warranty terms. Bowl interior color matches (both ship White as standard).

Pricing

Pricing is essentially identical at $175-195 depending on retailer and promotion. The Compact may be marginally cheaper at some retailers due to slightly lower production volume.

Real-world comfort

The 2-inch projection difference is consequential for adults using the toilet. Most adults find full elongated more comfortable for longer sit times. Children and households with mobility limitations find the difference minimal.