Head-to-Head Comparison

American Standard VorMax Compact-Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet vs American Standard Cadet 3 Compact-Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet

Toilets — Side-by-side spec comparison and expert verdict

VS
Our Verdict
We recommend the American Standard VorMax Compact for hard-water households — the rimless bowl design eliminates the rim-hole buildup that the Cadet 3 develops over time. For soft-water areas, the standard Cadet 3 saves $100-150 with no functional disadvantage...

Spec-by-Spec Comparison

Specification
American Standard
American Standard
Price
Check current price
Check current price
Rating
Glaze
EverClean
Standard ceramic (EverClean optional)
Design
Two-piece compact-elongated with VorMax flush
Two-piece compact-elongated, apartment-spec workhorse
Map Score
900
800
Bowl Shape
Compact Elongated
Compact Elongated
Flush Type
VorMax (circular flush + PowerWash rim)
FloWise Gravity (3-inch flush valve)
Watersense
1
1
Ada Compliant
1
1
Height Inches
17.25
16.5
Warranty Years
1
1
Rough In Inches
12
12
Gallons Per Flush
1.28
1.28
Warranty Porcelain
Lifetime
Lifetime

Detailed Comparison

VorMax Compact ($300-360) and Cadet 3 Compact ($175-195) share the same compact-elongated bowl shape and 1.28 GPF rating. The differentiator is rim design. The Cadet 3 has traditional rim holes that distribute water around the bowl during flush — these holes accumulate mineral scale in hard-water areas, weakening the flush over years. The VorMax Compact is rimless: one large angled jet at the back of the rim creates a sheet of water that sweeps the bowl from back to front. No rim holes to scale, more uniform bowl wash, easier cleaning. In hard-water regions (TDS over 200 ppm), the buildup difference is significant after 2-3 years; the VorMax stays cleaner. In soft-water regions, both perform equivalently.

Final Verdict

We recommend the American Standard VorMax Compact for hard-water households — the rimless bowl design eliminates the rim-hole buildup that the Cadet 3 develops over time. For soft-water areas, the standard Cadet 3 saves $100-150 with no functional disadvantage.

Choose American Standard if...

You prefer American Standard's strengths and feature set.

Buy American Standard — Check current price

Choose American Standard if...

You prefer American Standard's strengths and feature set.

Buy American Standard — Check current price

Pros & Cons Side-by-Side

American Standard VorMax Compact-Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet
Pros
  • VorMax flush technology in compact-elongated bowl (17.5")
  • EverClean glaze standard
  • Right Height (17.25") + WaterSense 1.28 GPF
  • PowerWash rim cleaning during flush
  • MaP 900g — between Cadet 3 (800g) and Champion 4 (1,000g+)
  • Apartment-spec upgrade path — premium feature in compact bowl
  • AmStd brand confidence at sub-$450
  • Less common in retail (slightly designer feel)
Cons
  • Premium pricing for two-piece compact ($320-$440)
  • Standard 3-inch flush valve (not Champion 4's 4-inch)
  • SoftClose seat NOT included
  • Less broadly distributed than Cadet 3 Compact
  • Compact-elongated bowl may feel small for taller adults
American Standard Cadet 3 Compact-Elongated 1.28 GPF Toilet
Pros
  • Compact-elongated bowl (17.5") fits smaller bathrooms
  • Same FloWise flush mechanism as standard Cadet 3 — MaP 800g
  • AmStd brand confidence at sub-$300
  • WaterSense 1.28 GPF certified
  • Comfort Height (16.5") + compact-elongated bowl
  • Universal aftermarket parts
  • Stocked at most Home Depot and Lowes
  • $20-$30 cheaper than Edgemere with same compact-elongated bowl
Cons
  • Standard ceramic glaze (no EverClean upgrade on base SKU)
  • SoftClose seat NOT included
  • Comfort Height (16.5") vs Edgemere's Right Height (17.25") — 0.75" lower seat
  • Compact-elongated may feel small for taller adult users
  • Less broadly distributed than standard Cadet 3 (full elongated)